Netflix’s ‘Mary’ Is Quite Contrary To Reality

Mary, did you know one day you’d be reimagined?

Before you hit play, you have to read what those behind the new Netflix film “Mary” — billed as a “survival thriller” — are saying to understand the direction Hollywood is going with the movie.

Released earlier this month, screenwriter Timothy Michael Hayes said, “One challenge was that they wanted (the) film to appeal to all denominations and all dogmas.”

The first hint at a modern-day inclusive Mary.

After all, they consulted Christian, Jewish, and Muslim leaders when writing the screenplay. Yes, Muslim leaders. Show of hands if you think Hollywood would consult Christians on a film about Mohammed. Me neither.

Bible-believing Christians are naturally upset about the liberties taken to recreate Mary. Director of “Mary,” D.J. Caruso, said he wanted to give the world a portrayal of the real, human Mary even though the Bible doesn’t have much to say about her.

And the anti-Israel crowd is coming in hot because an Israeli Jewish woman, Noa Cohen, was cast as Mary, the Jewish mother of Jesus. The calls for boycotts quickly went out on social media.

Let’s just be real: If you are in the habit of spewing anti-Semitism online, then you are probably never going to watch a movie about the mother of Jesus.

Cohen, clearly has no idea who Mary was, saying, 

Mary’s being portrayed in a whole new light in my opinion. It’s giving her her voice back. She’s not just a vessel for something greater than herself.

Actually, that’s exactly who the mother of Jesus was. Saying she’s “not just a vessel” is an ignorant statement — as if it’s not enough to be chosen by God as a key instrument in His perfect plan to bring His son to earth so that He may be the ultimate sacrifice for our salvation, as Christians believe. This production brings an obvious feminist twist and an attempt to modernize Mary with an actress who doesn’t understand her story or purpose.

“Mary.” Netflix. Aloe Entertainment. Creativity Media. IMDB.

With some exceptions, faith-based movies often ping-pong between being cringe-worthy or missing the biblical mark. A mark they likely never intended to hit.

When I heard that prosperity gospel megachurch pastor Joel Osteen was an executive producer of Mary, I was fairly confident this movie would plant itself in the second camp, landing short of the biblical target. Gaining health and wealth is at the center of the prosperity gospel, and generally absent of sound biblical theology.

CHECK OUT THE DAILY WIRE HOLIDAY GIFT GUIDE

On X, Osteen teased the movie, saying, “See Mary like you’ve never seen her before.” Tell me you’re not going to stick to the Bible without telling me.

If you hit play, right out of the gate, Mary opens the film with, “You may think you know my story. Trust me, you don’t.”

Trust me, Netflix, we do — for the Bible tells us so.

Friendly PSA: If you’re letting Hollywood teach you theology, you’re doing it wrong.

It’s bad enough Disney is tragically “reimagining” their classics — one painful reboot at a time. Their second attempt at reimagining “Snow White” comes out next year, and includes seven computer-generated “magical creatures” instead of dwarfs and a Latina Snow White who publicly trashed the original “Snow White.” In spite of the politically correct ring kissing having no floor or ceiling — you can never bend the woke knee enough, even for magical creatures — everyone understands animated fairytales are fiction. That doesn’t change the fact that liberties taken with Dopey and Sneezy are still dumb. For a majority of Americans, however, the Bible is not fiction. Adherence to its original context without ad libbing an agenda is something many of us take very seriously. 

Director of “Mary,” D.J. Caruso, said, 

The world needs to see Mary, and they need to see her in a new light. My goal was to see if I could present Mary in a beautiful way, in a way that a younger audience could see her and relate to her as not just this beautiful, iconic holy mother, but as a young girl who had to make sacrifices and struggle and deal with things that a lot of the contemporary youth are dealing with today.

While, no doubt, young girls today have serious struggles and make sacrifices, none will ever be able to relate to being chosen to carry the Savior of the world through an immaculate conception and the potential earthly consequences she may have faced. The most they can do is respect her faithfulness.

A bright light has been shining on Mary for more than 2,000 years. Her story and her obedience to God are just as beautiful and relevant today as it was back then.

If God wanted us to have a different take on Mary, He would have provided one and not waited more than 2,000 years for Netflix to offer its take.

In “Mary,” her cousin Elizabeth tells her, “Trust the strength inside of you.” It sounds eerily like the gospel of self-actualization trending in today’s “me” centered culture. It also sounds like something you’d hear straight from Joel Osteen.

Hollywood doesn’t need to give the mother of Jesus a reboot in order to reach large audiences and reap the financial rewards. On the rare occasion it does produce a film that’s faithful to Scripture, such as “The Passion of the Christ,” audiences turn out in droves — to the tune of over $600 million at the box office.

Hollywood is great at making Hallmark movies, but not so much with theologically accurate narratives.

Caruso wants us to believe that Mary is “sort of a superhero without powers.” The film wraps with Mary — the superhero — announcing that “Love will save the world.”

Nice bumper sticker, but if you’re a Christian, you know that it’s God’s Son who came to save the world, and He’s the only superhero in this story.

* * *

Lauren DeBellis Appell, a former lobbyist and communications aide on Capitol Hill, is a writer based in Fairfax, Virginia. Follow her on X @LDAppell.

The views expressed in this piece are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of The Daily Wire.