The Urgent Need for the UK’s Muslim Rape Gang Inquiry and Lessons for the US

The United Kingdom’s grooming gangs scandal, recently cited by Elon Musk, serves as a warning to the United States as the nation deals with issues of sex trafficking and child exploitation due to immigration policies.

In 2025, Musk made nearly 200 posts, amplifying abuse allegations and paralleling U.S. concerns about exploitation and community influences.

On Monday, hearings began for U.K. Member of Parliament Rupert Lowe’s independent Rape Gang Inquiry. The inquiry is a crowdfunded investigation into the reported grooming, rape, and exploitation of up to one million vulnerable girls over five decades across the country.

Lowe’s initiative seeks to address perceived government inaction. However, his reversal on promised transparency—after raising funds on that basis—has drawn criticism. This may expose Lowe to legal risks from misled donors and highlights possible lessons for American child protection policy.

The Necessity of the Inquiry: Confronting a History of Organizational Failures

For over 50 years, mostly white English and some Sikh girls from disadvantaged backgrounds were systematically exploited by Muslim Pakistani groups.

In Rotherham, 1,400 children suffered abuse between 1997 and 2013 while authorities allegedly ignored reports to avoid accusations of racism. Similar incidents in up to 40 other towns contributed to national estimates as high as 1 million victims.

Successive governments have not adequately addressed the issue.

Conservative administrations commissioned fragmented reviews, while Labour’s June commitment resulted in the December appointment of Baroness Anne Longfield CBE as chair, along with several panelists, for a statutory inquiry scheduled to begin in March.

At least ten major inquiries have examined grooming and child exploitation, but none focused exclusively on national grooming gangs.

Local reviews, including in Derby, Rochdale, Rotherham, Oxford, Telford, and Oldham, and national efforts like the Home Affairs Committee, Children’s Commissioner, and the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse, revealed systemic failures but lacked focus, enabling perpetrators to evade justice.

The 2025 Casey audit called for a dedicated investigation, but delays persist. This parallels U.S. concerns about unchecked migration and potential abuses.

Rupert Lowe’s Key Contributions

As the Member of Parliament for Great Yarmouth, Lowe raised over 600,000 pounds ($820,000) through crowdfunding from 20,000 donors. His team, which includes survivor Sammy Woodhouse, identified exploitation in 85 authorities, flagged 1,200 cases (including 200 high-priority cases), and applied pressure on Labour’s inquiry. Through the Restore Britain initiative, Lowe elevates survivor voices and advocates for in-depth reviews and improved protection measures.

Rupert Lowe’s Commitment to Transparency and Its Subsequent Reversal

During his crowdfunding campaign, Lowe pledged that “Stage 2—Public Hearings” would involve “a multiple-day live-streamed hearing period. Hearings will be closed to the public (for safety and control) but broadcast online to guarantee transparency.” This promise of transparency was central to securing donor support, particularly given the history of cover-ups associated with the scandal.

However, this commitment has since been reversed.

Sessions are now held behind closed doors, with no livestreaming and only selected evidence released to the public. Media access is prohibited. This change has sparked fierce criticism, including from former panel member Donna Rachel Edmunds, who branded the inquiry “an utter shambles” and cited inadequate funding, a lack of safeguarding, poor methodology, and her abrupt dismissal after proposing professional support.

Critics argue Lowe’s U-turn betrays donors who funded based on openness, potentially opening him to legal action for misleading representations or breach of terms, eroding trust and jeopardizing the inquiry’s credibility in a scandal demanding full accountability.

The Pursuit of Prosecutions Amid Systemic Obstacles

Lowe’s created his inquiry to facilitate private prosecutions against individuals who enabled abuse. However, achieving justice remains difficult, as demonstrated by the case of “Liz,” who secured a £450,000 judgment against her assailant, Asghar Bostan, in 2023 with support from Robin Tilbrook, Lord Pearson, and Hearts of Oak. Despite this legal victory, no enforcement order has been issued after five years.

Lowe’s inquiry strives to address five decades of institutional neglect.

Although previous investigations have identified significant issues, none have focused exclusively on national grooming networks, showing the need for renewed transparency.

While successful prosecutions could deliver justice, persistent enforcement issues, as demonstrated in Liz’s case, continue. For the United States, this situation illustrates the potential risks of favoring diversity over public safety and stresses the importance of vigilant policy measures to prevent similar abuses.

We publish a variety of perspectives. Nothing written here is to be construed as representing the views of The Daily Signal.

The post The Urgent Need for the UK’s Muslim Rape Gang Inquiry and Lessons for the US appeared first on The Daily Signal.