How Not To Ruin Your Thanksgiving – The Meal At Least

Nov 21, 2026 - 04:00
0 0
How Not To Ruin Your Thanksgiving – The Meal At Least
Freedom Is Back In Style - 728x90 Ad

Premium domains for sale

Freedom Is Back In Style

FreedomIsBackInStyle .COM .NET .ORG WhereFreedomIsBackInStyle .COM .NET .ORG
Six-domain portfolio: $300,000 View Domains

Bart Hutchins, the founding chef of Butterworth’s, is one of the most accomplished chefs in America. He is also a crusader against D.C. zealots for the freedom to serve foie gras. He spoke to us about how to save your turkey day, in detail.

Freedom Is Back In Style - 300x250 Ad

Freedom Is Back
In Style

Premium domains for sale

FreedomIsBackInStyle.com .COM   .NET   .ORG
Packages from $100,000 View Domains

***

Ben Domenech: I want to talk to you about the upcoming holidays and the decisions that people make as they relate to food. I know that you’re not just a chef, but you’re someone who pays attention to both the pressures that are on families and all the different decisions that people make, and how they cut corners, how they try to figure things out, especially when they feel like they need to tighten the belt to the point where most people want to expand it. Now, because we’re Americans, we end up spending more money every year, despite the doomsayers. But I did want to get your counsel on this because this is a really good time to remind people that they can prioritize. When it comes to family decision-making around the holidays and holiday meals, what do you see as the things they should prioritize, and what should they be willing to put lower down the list or ditch entirely?

Bart Hutchins: That is a great question. Every year I watch the price of the cans and pre-made stuff go up and up. So, you walk through the grocery store right now, you’ll see the fried onions that people put on casseroles, the canned pumpkin pie filling, the cranberries — and all that stuff is great — I think we all have a place for it, but it’s getting more and more expensive every year. Whereas the ingredients to make those things, like the price of pumpkins, aren’t significantly higher. The price of onions isn’t significantly higher. And so it’s really a shame that we’re being forced to do this. We have to ask questions about what’s more valuable for the amount of time we’re going to spend making something. And I think the upside to that is making all this stuff for yourself is way better.

Now, I don’t want to be unrealistic. I think Americans are almost as pressed for time now as they are for money. I’m not even arguing — they’re more pressed for time — and how they get away with charging an arm and a leg that they are for things that don’t require much labor. But most farmers’ markets in the country are still running until after Thanksgiving; that’s usually when they pack up shop for the winter, and they are ready with all of these ingredients, and you can be there, you can meet these farmers, you can buy things from them. And I would encourage it. The vegetable choices on American Thanksgiving tables tend to be one of the weakest parts.

Ben: I would actually say as someone who’s going over the menu for my own family this year and figuring out what I’m going to make, part of that is going to be informed by the farmers’ market that I usually go to this weekend when it comes to the vegetable part of this. That’s the area where, if you get something that’s actually fresh and good, you can entice people to eat it, even though their natural tendency is to be tempted by everything else on the table. What’s an example of that from your perspective that people should look out for?

Bart: Right now we are in peak carrots, Brussels sprouts, butternut squash season. All of it is just beautiful and multicolored and gorgeous. And you don’t have to mix any of it with cream of mushroom soup. You can just cook them with a little bit of maple syrup or whatever it may be, and they’re delicious. So I would look for Brussels sprouts, I’d look for carrots, I’d look for the fall squashes — honeynuts, butternut, all these.

Ben: What’s your preference when it comes to making squash for the table? Do you have a particular approach that you like for one or the other?

Bart: Yes. So I find that squash and nuts go really well together. So you can make almost any squash, like a Blue Hubbard or a butternut squash. There are five million varieties of squash. Go pick the prettiest one. And if you cook it and serve it with these three things, it’ll be delicious no matter what. First, add some form of sweetener. So you could sprinkle it with a little bit of brown sugar. I prefer maple syrup. I’ve seen people make fake syrups and stuff, but something that’s sweet. Add something that’s a little bit spicy. I’ve seen people throw in some Fresno chili; I’ve seen people dust it with a little bit of chili powder. Paprika is my favorite. Sweet, spicy, and then some form of roasted nuts. So if you get some pecans or hazelnuts or walnuts or whatever it is, if you pick your own adventure out of those three categories and have that with any squash, it will be delicious. Full stop.

Add salt and pepper, obviously. But if you don’t overcook it till it’s mush and you have those three things, it will taste good.

Ben: When it comes to making stuffing, are you opposed to buying the pre-dried bags of bread cubes that they sell on the endcaps of every grocery store at this time of year?

Bart: I’m not. I really am conscious of the fact that Americans, as I said earlier, probably have less time than they do money these days. And so you have to do what you have to do. I will say with a little bit of planning and pre-scheduling, saving up some stale bread is not particularly difficult for a lot of people. And that’s all you’re really looking for. But stale bread is in your house right now for free, and you’re going to just throw it in the garbage.

Ben: The conversation that exists around how much time to invest in one dish or another is always the thing that people are trying to manage when it comes to trading off, especially when you’re typically working with one oven at home. So when people are making that decision, what do you think makes the biggest difference between being an oven product versus being an on-the-stove product?

Bart: I find for my personal Thanksgiving menu, almost everything is an oven thing. And so it’s really about timing that out well. There are usually two racks in your oven; your turkey’s at the bottom, and then you have an empty one on top. And then it’s about what you’re cycling in and what needs to be the hottest at the end. And so for me, Brussels sprouts, squash, stuff like that, if it comes down to slightly below steaming hot, sitting on the stovetop or waiting for the rest of the stuff to come out, that’s not the end of the world to me. But if the mac and cheese or the mashed potatoes comes out lukewarm — there’s something about dairy products that are prone to congealing that just makes it awful.

So anything that’s heavy dairy, some of your casseroles, your mashed potatoes, your mac and cheese, whatever it may be, those have to be absolutely last. Whereas some of your vegetables are perfectly fine being out. So that’s priority for me. Another priority is this: If you’re not brining your turkey by the time you read this, you should probably just cook a ham.

Ben: Okay. But when you say brine, you now have to be specific because lots of people use brine in different ways and refer to different things. And there are even some people who say that a dry brine is not a thing that exists and that, in reality, you should call it something else. What is your take on brining?

Bart: For turkey, I prefer a wet brine because I need more liquid. When you’re brining something, really you’re adding salt to its muscles. So the same way we drink Gatorade to hold onto water, that’s basically what you do when you brine something. So I prefer a wet brine on turkey because it is such a lean animal and I need it to hang onto as much moisture as possible. I prefer a dry brine when I want very crispy skin. So I tend to dry brine chickens when I roast them because they’re a little bit juicier than turkey. And what’s really important to me is getting the skin crispy.

Ben: But let’s say that you are in a place where you are not getting a heritage bird — you are not getting this from a farm, you are getting either the Butterball or something along those lines, maybe something a step up from that at your local Walmart, for example. Do you still prefer a wet brine for those, or should people go dry?

Bart: I still prefer wet on a turkey; I prefer four days. Anything north of two, you’ll really notice the difference, but I really prefer a long brine on turkey because they are still eating them. The dry brine can totally work. And in fact, I think there’s an argument to be made that if you forgot until the night before, dry brine might be your best bet for no other reason than you’re getting seasoning on the bird. And most people’s problem with home cooking is that they almost always don’t use enough salt. So that’s a decent reason for dry brining. I find most people — that’s what they’re experiencing when they dry brine something is that they just seasoned it properly for the first time ever.

Ben: I appreciate both, but the last couple of years I’ve used dry because we have had to travel. When you have to travel and you’re getting to a cabin or a friend’s house a day or two before, it’s a lot easier to transport a bird and bring what you’re doing in the dry brine than to transport a wet bird. For people who have not even done this before, the folks you’re talking about, when they use a dry brine or when they use a wet, they’re doing something for the first time, basically. What do you think they need to include, if anything, other than salt to make a great bird?

Bart: It depends on your volume, of course, but I tend to use one-fourth the amount of sugar as I use salt. Specifically on a turkey, this does a few things, and number one is that it helps your skin caramelize so you can have both a juicy bird and a slightly crispier skin because the residual sugars help caramelize. I’m not a scientist, but I find it helps the brine work better. There’s something about the alchemy that’s happening there. So there should always be a little bit of sugar in a brine. I usually go about one-fourth of the amount of salt.

You’ve heard of kitchen steak; well, brining is very kitchen steak. I’m like, oh, I got a couple of lemons in here, I’m going to cut those up and throw those in. I’ve got some parsley stems. I already picked all the parsley leaves, so I’m going to throw the parsley stems in there. The only thing that’s sort of mandatory is salt, sugar, and then some sort of dry spice. I find allspice to be nice. If you’re really hoity-toity, I find juniper berries nice. Whatever dry spices in your cabinet are good. Salt, sugar, and a dry spice are the mandatory ones. I would also recommend some citrus, but the first three are mandatory.

Ben: When it comes to stuffing, do you have a preferred kind? Do you lean in one direction or another?

Bart: I really like a classic oyster stuffing, and I’ll do it inside of the bird despite how risky that is. I have a relatively small family, so I don’t need a whole casserole of stuffing.

Ben: Not even for yourself to enjoy later in the middle of the night?

Bart: It’s never been my favorite part, but I do like the oyster stuffing. And I like having it inside the bird because I roast it very traditionally. It looks like a cartoon bird being roasted. I truss the legs together, and I stuff it. Part of the original reason we started stuffing turkeys was to fill that cavity to make sure heat isn’t penetrating too much on the breast and not enough on the legs, and keeps everything even. And I find that to be true when I do the stuffing; I just get a more even roast on everything.

Ben: I’ve used tons of different methods, as I’m sure other home cooks have, when it comes to cooking turkey. The problem is that sometimes, especially if you’re not at a home or if you’re using someone else’s oven for some reason, you can’t really trust it. You don’t know where the hotspots are, or how much you can trust the heat. Even if you’re choosing a thermometer or even a digital thermometer, it’s kind of a crapshoot. So the method that I have ended up doing a couple of times — and I want you to critique it, and you can tell me if I’m completely wrong — is I do the turkey breast en cocotte, and then I do the dark meat separately.

Bart: The way I actually make turkey at home, if I’m doing a full turkey for Thanksgiving, I usually do one the traditional way because everybody wants to see a bird on the table. If I go home for the holidays, it’s usually a two-bird occasion at that point anyway because it goes from me and my wife and my child to 30 people or so. My favorite way I’ve ever done turkey is this: I remove the breasts, roast those separately, and then confit the legs the same way you would duck confit. So cure them, dry-brine them, and cure them for two or three days, then drop them in duck fat and cook them very slowly. And that confit turkey leg, it’s better than everybody’s deep-fried turkey and smoked turkey and all these other random techniques that people want to come up with. It is the single best way to eat turkey.

Ben: Do you have a preferred dark meat confit recipe from a chef?

Bart: I don’t know. I’ve never even looked, but basically I’ll take my duck confit pure — which is just salt, sugar, paprika, tarragon, and cure the turkey legs for two or three days. So rub them down with that mixture, cover them. And I’ll rinse them off and reseason them, drop them in a pan of duck fat, and then leave them in the oven all morning, preferably around 300. And I’ll leave them in there even as I’m pulling other stuff in and out. So if I get to 400, it’ll be 10 minutes or so to get crispy skin, but my roasting oven temperature is 300 all day.

Ben: You just mentioned the tarragon. For the sake of folks at home, what spices should they be sure to use fresh, and what should they use dried?

Bart: This is really actually very simple. If it is an herb, it should be fresh. If it is a spice, it should be dry. And so parsley, tarragon, chives, rosemary, thyme — if you have the dry version, open your cabinet and throw it away. It tastes like a horse stable floor. It’s a really pointless thing that we were all sold on in the 1990s, and we still have them for some reason. And so all your herbs, if you can, they should be fresh. And then everything else should be dry. So nutmeg should be dry, allspice should be dry, cinnamon, et cetera.

Ben: When it comes to mashed potatoes, people have different methods and preferences. What is your preferred approach? And when it comes to the dairy that’s used, are you pro or anti the certain shortcuts that people recommend, like cream cheese or sour cream, when it comes to mashed potatoes?

Bart: Potatoes are very forgiving. First and foremost, it’s my favorite part of the meal. There’s no wrong way to do it. The worst thing you can do is serve under-salted potatoes. That is miserable. But the sour cream thing is fine. The milk thing is fine. The mayonnaise thing is even better than both of those in my opinion. All of that’s fine. There is, however, one platonic perfect way to make mashed potatoes, which is only four ingredients: potatoes, salt, butter, and pepper. And the important part is after you boil your potatoes, you need to use a potato ricer or a food mill to separate the potato chunks because they do have this sort of gluey quality.

Ben: Most men will be familiar with either of those devices as the one thing that is blocking the drawer when you try to open it for the rest of the year.

Bart: I tell the American families, they ought to have one around just to make gnocchi with. So you get your potatoes, you boil the potatoes, you put them through the food mill, and you put those in a large bowl over a warm surface. In a professional kitchen, you do it over a steaming pot of water. And then, working by volume, you are taking cold chunks of butter that are equal in volume to the amount of potatoes you have. It’s always more butter than you think you need, every single time.

And then after you’ve worked all that in slowly so that it incorporates and not just melts and sits on top, then you run it back through your food mill or ricer again. And then season with salt and pepper. That is the perfect potato and the thing I look forward to every Thanksgiving.

Ben: Mac and cheese is the obsession of the youngest people at the table and perhaps the oldest, but they don’t admit it. Do you have a high-level and a low-level approach to mac and cheese? Because you can really elevate it, or you can also cut corners and use evaporated milk, and it actually will come out really good if you do it right, at least in my experience.

Bart: To my palate, using Velveeta is a better option than most people who make mac and cheese with a béchamel and then the bag of shredded cheese that’s hanging next to the deli meat in the grocery store.

I would rather have Velveeta any day. It’s designed to have the right texture, and it’s homemade mac and cheese; it can be very good, but unless we’re going to sort of do it right, I think the Velveeta is almost always better.

On the doing it right, there are a lot of ways to do it. All of them involve taking béchamel and then stirring your cheeses of choice into that béchamel. What I found when I’m trying to elevate it is getting the right mixture of cheese into that béchamel. And the one that’s really, really made the difference for me, because it kind of mimics that Velveeta, is getting a Fontina or a Raclette or an aged Gouda. One of the cheeses has a stringy quality when it melts; pair that with your more classic cheddars, and you get the proper texture. So when you go to take a big scoop out of the mac and cheese casserole, it has that same thing.

Ben: So basically what I’m hearing is if you’re going to go processed, this is the one area where that’s okay because it mimics it as closely as possible.

Bart: In my opinion, the two areas to go processed, if you must, if you need to save time, are the mac and cheese and the cranberry sauce.

Ben: Yes, I completely agree. When I make it, I like it, but it requires bringing more things and remembering the Grand Marnier and that kind of thing. And the kids don’t care.

Bart: I’m as organic and crunchy as we get, and there’s still nothing I can do.

Ben: I want to ask you about the gravy. The approach that I have is using the bunch of vegetables that are underneath that turkey breast. They’re getting the juices, and then you take the breast out, and either you’re leaving the dark meat in, but you’ve got all these vegetables, and you’ve got a stock in there, and you can strain it and you can use it as the base and work from there. There are lots of people who have all sorts of complicated gravy recipes. Are any of them actually worth it?

Bart: The whole point of gravy is to make use of the parts of the animal that we can’t eat: the bones, the grease on the bottom of the breast. All of the things that we don’t eat, the philosophical purpose of gravy is to make use of those things. And God rewards us by doing the right thing and using those wasted products by it being also the most delicious thing in the world.

That is the system that was divinely set up: if you do the work and don’t waste this bird, I will reward you with gravy. So yes, I’m a big fan of the way you mentioned, which is using the stuff that’s left over in the roasting. When I do the turkey method where I separate the breasts, separate the legs, I do a whole stock with the carcass and then reduce that down and make my gravy that way. That is my honest-to-God preference. In a restaurant, that’s what we do with every single bird — duck, pheasant or turkey, whatever. We separate all the parts. We use the bones to make stock; we use the stuff to make a sauce.

Most grocery stores now — I’ve noticed this recently, even in my local grocery store out in West Virginia, not just Whole Foods — I’ve noticed bones again in my local grocery store. You used to be able to get them all the time, and then they kind of disappeared, and now they seem to be coming back. Picking up a handful of extra of those to throw into your stock that you’re going to make into your gravy, it’s never a bad decision. And it doesn’t have to be the same animal, like throwing a couple of beef bones into your turkey sauce.

Ben: For dessert, because from my perspective, when you’re a home cook and you are making 75 to 80% of the meal yourself, you have to choose an area where you’re going to cut corners. And for me, that has always been the desserts only because I’m not as good at baking, and I feel like there are plenty of people out there who make great pies. Is that okay to do, or should I be ashamed that I’m not making my chocolate bourbon pecan pie, which I know is really, really good when I make it, but it takes time?

Bart: Maybe it’s because I’ve never been any kind of pastry chef, but I really would prefer for somebody else to make dessert. When I go home to see my full family, I make an arrangement with everyone because I’m a professional chef, so I’ll make everything, literally. All of you have to bring dessert. That’s fantastic. I have a skillset that not everybody has, but that is how much I would prefer not to make dessert.

Number one, in a really civilized world where we all live like kings, dessert and savory would not even be made in the same kitchen. The fact that desserts are always sticky and goopy and they’re all over the place and they’re so messy is the opposite of everything I do when I’m cooking savory. I really just don’t want to be interrupted by a totally separate task.

There’s momentum in sautéing vegetables and making gravy at the same time. There’s no momentum to stop to weigh the amount of flour that you’re going to put on this thing. It’s awful.

Ben: Is there one particular non-traditional dish that you think people should appreciate more or include in their holiday meals that is higher quality than they might suspect, or maybe they’ve never tried it before, or they just don’t associate with the holidays?

Bart: Goose. That was the first thing that crossed my mind. Also, one of the things that I do when I’m the main cook is, early in the morning, I take a small pumpkin, a pie pumpkin, and I pull the seeds out. I stuff it — I throw in some mushrooms, some stale bread, and a bunch of melty cheese, like Brie or Fontina again or something that gets gooey, with a little heavy cream, put the top back on it, and roast that in the oven. And then I sit that out wherever everybody’s hanging out.

Number one, it looks cool, and people just aren’t used to that being an appetizer. And number two, it has the same exact quality as just making fondue. And so people start picking up little vegetables and breaking the bread and dipping it into this pumpkin. That’s a really fun one.


More from this network:
Domains for Sale · GOTPeople.org · TheDSAPlatform · The Truth About Socialism

Donate to GOTPeople.org

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0
Fibis

I am just an average American. My teen years were in the late 70s and I participated in all that that decade offered. Started working young, too young. Then I joined the Army before I graduated High School. I spent 25 years in, mostly in Infantry units. Since then I've worked in information technology positions all at small family owned companies. At this rate I'll never be a tech millionaire. When I was young I rode horses as much as I could. I do believe I should have been a cowboy. I'm getting in the saddle again by taking riding lessons and see where it goes.

Freedom Is Back In Style - 728x90 Ad

Premium domains for sale

Freedom Is Back In Style

FreedomIsBackInStyle .COM .NET .ORG WhereFreedomIsBackInStyle .COM .NET .ORG
Six-domain portfolio: $300,000 View Domains

Comments (0)

User