The Last Chapter The Left Might Want To Reread Before Betting On Islamists
Premium domains for sale
Freedom Is Back In Style
This is republished with permission by the author. The original, “America Is Walking Into Houellebecq’s Nightmare,” can be found here.
Freedom Is Back
In Style
Premium domains for sale
Subscribe to Restoring the West here.
***
No living French writer matters more — or provokes the liberal chattering classes more fiercely — than Michel Houellebecq, whose latest run-in with the law has reignited debate. Now, the 70-year-old novelist and nonconformist finds himself under criminal investigation for comments he made in a 2022 interview with Front Populaire. Houellebecq said that he, like millions of native French people, wants Muslims to stop assaulting and pillaging people or simply pack their bags and find a new home. It’s an entirely reasonable request, considering France now finds itself overrun by violent, radical thugs from North Africa and the Middle East. French authorities, however, see it differently. His remarks have revived a familiar controversy over free speech, hate speech, and responsibility in civil society across L’Hexagone.
But the controversy reaches beyond what Houellebecq said to what France has long refused to confront. For three decades, Houellebecq has diagnosed the West’s decline, traced its cultural transformation, and warned of the erosion of traditional values and beliefs. His novels expose what politicians prefer to ignore, often with a bluntness that offends even those who recognize the truth in his warnings. Houellebecq can be crude. But one can object to his language without dismissing his foresight. On the political and cultural impact of Islam in France and beyond, he has consistently hit the mark.
And that is precisely why he, rather than those responsible for this festering disease, finds himself under investigation. Better to prosecute the man for delivering an unwelcome and uncomfortably accurate message than confront the problems he has identified — particularly where, as with his comments about France’s Muslim minority, those problems stir sentiments far more widespread than the politically correct establishment cares to acknowledge.
If a single Houellebecq novel captures his prophetic vision, it is “Submission.” Published in 2015, his most famous work appeared on the very day of the Charlie Hebdo massacre, when Islamist terrorists stormed the Paris offices of the French satirical magazine, killing 12 people and injuring 11. Had that brutal attack not occurred, many critics would have brushed “Submission” off as little more than dystopian speculation. Instead, even Houellebecq’s fiercest detractors had to confront a work of fiction that held a mirror up to a crisis already unfolding.
The novel centers on the run-up to the 2022 presidential election, when Mohammed Ben Abbes, the urbane, apparently moderate leader of the new Muslim Fraternity party, faces Marine Le Pen of the Front National in the decisive second round. What makes the novel so unsettling, however, is that Ben Abbes, whose election becomes the fulcrum of France’s transformation into an Islamic state, neither seizes power through a coup nor leads a jihadist revolution. The French political establishment itself clears his path to the presidency, since neither the Socialist Party nor its center-right counterparts can stomach the alternative. The specter of fascism so thoroughly haunts French politics that Le Pen and her ilk come to embody its ultimate threat. To the establishment, handing the keys of the state to a would-be Islamizer is still preferable to letting her take the Élysée.
“Submission”’s genius is its refusal to give us cartoonish villains. Ben Abbes is no frothing-at-the-mouth extremist. Suave, soft-spoken, and politically shrewd, he understands how to work within the very institutions he intends to transform. He also grasps how little Western liberalism’s professed values resemble the convictions of those who wield power in its name. And so, when France finally submits to Islam, the transformation unfolds almost imperceptibly. No pitched battles erupt in the streets. The Sorbonne simply becomes an Islamic university, its coffers swelling with Saudi petrodollars. Women are barred from teaching. Polygamy becomes legal. And François, the novel’s po-faced, middle-of-the-road literature professor, embraces the Prophet’s word not through a religious epiphany but because conversion promises him a higher salary, a measure of stability, and several young, beautiful wives.
“Submission” may be set in France, but its politics are anything but parochial. Across the Atlantic, Houellebecq’s dystopia has begun to look less like speculative fiction and more like a blueprint for subversion, with ominous implications for the future of the United States.
For years, we’ve consoled ourselves with the notion that what ails Europe can find no purchase on American soil. Here, we still have a strong culture of Christian observance, a robust economy, and — most crucially — an assimilationist tradition that has, historically speaking, transformed immigrants from Warsaw to Wolfsburg into fully fledged Americans within a single generation.
But we can no longer afford such complacency. In the wake of the recent midterms, such optimism looks increasingly naive. Conservatives did not merely suffer a humiliating defeat at the ballot box. The far left secured victories by forging an alliance that contradicts everything this great nation represents. The alliance is, of course, red and green — and its influence continues to grow.
Witness, for instance, how progressive politics has transformed our nation’s cities and college towns over the past few years. Backed by groups such as the DSA, progressives have stormed municipal, state, and federal elections, racking up victories in New York, Minnesota, Michigan, and elsewhere through an unholy union of our nation’s secular socialists and its resolutely radical Islamist blocs.
The contradictions are, naturally enough, legion. Progressives who decry “patriarchy” and defend abortion-on-demand must also genuflect before those who reject the very principles they claim to uphold. We have already seen the strain this imbecilic arrangement imposes, not least when progressives recoiled after Hamtramck, Michigan’s all-Muslim city council — only recently hailed as staunch allies — voted to bar Pride flags from flying on city property.
But as long as there are common foes to fight, from American exceptionalism and Judeo-Christian values to those who believe Israel has a right to exist, progressives can tolerate such compromises. DSA-endorsed politicians readily adopt political Islam’s anti-colonial rhetoric, echoing cries of “resistance!” in unison. They see themselves as wise and enlightened; in reality, they are little more than well-placed fools, destined to be discarded once their usefulness expires.
As Ben Abbes discovered, nothing mollifies the Left more than being cast as a bulwark against racism and injustice. And few ideas have taken deeper hold among progressives than the conviction that the West is the root of all evil. Yet what begins as a tactical alliance ends in total subjugation. The Islamists seize full control and turn on the useful idiots who helped bring them to power. America, I fear, is rapidly approaching this point.
Alliances built not on common values, but on mutual expediency are, by their nature, unstable. Sooner or later, the cracks appear, and one side prevails over the other. The side that believes most fervently in its own cause will inevitably triumph over the side that believes in nothing. Throughout “Submission,” naive enablers behave as though they will retain control over their fair-weather allies, as though they can somehow outsmart, outmaneuver, out-liberalize them. But progressives’ decades-long efforts to dismantle Western civilization’s moral, national, and religious foundations have left them with little ammunition to fight back. And what, after all, could stand in starker opposition to Islam and Islamists than progressivism’s cocktail of biological denialism, apathy, self-loathing, and empty procedure?
It’s perhaps no accident, then, that Michel Houellebecq finds himself in the crosshairs. What better exposes progressives’ moral and political bankruptcy than a society so bereft of confidence in its own values that it reaches for the criminal code rather than engaging in open argument? A society secure in its convictions answers its critics — refuting them where they are wrong, learning from them where they are not. A society that senses its own decline can only shout “silence!” and hope no one notices.
That Houellebecq’s work continues to provoke such responses only underscores its importance. Nowhere else is the West’s self-abnegation so clearly laid bare, its demise so matter-of-factly chronicled, as in his novels. And nowhere does the Western political class recoil more violently from the questions those novels raise. For what, ultimately, is “Submission” but an exploration of what happens when societies scorn their own traditions, abandon the defense of their borders, and welcome those who wish to see them replaced? The answers are already emerging in towns and cities across France, and increasingly across parts of America. Should progressives continue to mistake capitulation for tolerance, it may not be long before we discover just how prophetic Michel Houellebecq’s work truly was.
***
Ayaan Hirsi Ali is a women’s rights activist, bestselling author, founder of the AHA Foundation, and creator of Restoring the West.
More from this network:
Domains for Sale · GOTPeople.org · TheDSAPlatform · The Truth About Socialism
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Premium domains for sale
Comments (0)