In MLB’s Salary Cap Propaganda War, Players Must Offer More Than Stubborn Refusals
Premium domains for sale
Freedom Is Back In Style
This article was written by Jason Foster and published on Sport & State, a new media company founded by Clay Travis that is built around sports, culture, original voices, and live conversation.* * * * *
Freedom Is Back
In Style
Premium domains for sale
We’re about two weeks from a near-certain MLB lockout, and here’s what we know: The players do not want a salary cap. What we don’t know is what the players do want.
As the Dec. 1 expiration of the current collective bargaining agreement approaches, the MLB Players Association has yet to offer any public counter-proposal to a salary cap. It’s just been an immediate and standard Nope. Next. to every salvo from the owners.
Meanwhile, the owners have been all about public messaging. In fact, with the full backing of the league’s vast communication resources, they’ve essentially framed their entire proposal for a cap around public opinion polls that show a majority of fans would support one in the name of competitive balance.
With commercials, videos, and social media posts, their message has been clear: A salary cap is what’s best for the game, what’s best for fans, and what’s best for the players. It’s about competitive balance, about keeping baseball healthy and thriving.
Baseball fans have repeatedly told us they have two issues with the game today: blackouts and fairness
We’re proposing to make three major changes to baseball:
1. Entering into a partnership with players where all revenues that are generated are split 50/50 between the teams and the players
2. Implementing a salary cap and floor that will regulate what each team can spend
3. Revenues from media generated in baseball are shared equally by the clubs
This will reduce the revenue disparity in baseball and help us address local blackouts
Major League players’ total compensation would go up and fans would get a more competitive game
It’s a win for everybody
— MLB (@MLB) November 13, 2026
The MLBPA, on the other hand, has said almost literally nothing, other than absolutely not (and the occasionally individual pushback on X) because it doesn’t believe a cap is about anything other than increasing franchise values to benefit the owners.
But players need to start offering more than that. Because lots of fans really do believe baseball’s economics are broken. They really do believe their favorite team has no realistic shot to win the World Series or keep their best players beyond their initial contracts. They really do believe a salary cap and floor would help a lot.
So the players need to present an alternative. They need to publicly offer something that says to owners, Listen, we know you want to boost your teams’ values, so here’s a better idea and something that says to the fans, Hey, we hear you about competitive balance, so here’s what we’d do.
To be clear: Neither the players nor the owners are under any legal or moral obligation to share their ideas publicly. The only parties that matter are the ones negotiating. But as I wrote a couple of weeks ago, public opinion does matter. It won’t settle the salary cap issue, but it shouldn’t be ignored. The goal of CBA talks isn’t to win a PR war, but it certainly helps to have the public on your side.
Multiple polls over the past year have shown solid-to-strong public support for a salary cap, mostly driven by those competitive balance perceptions. So when fans hear a proposal from the owners that includes a salary cap and floor, a 50-50 revenue split, and other things that seem attractive on the surface, it’s easy to support, especially when players in other leagues seem to thrive under similar systems.
MLB needs to learn from the NFL. The most successful sports league in America understands that competitive balance is essential. You can’t have teams spending hundreds of millions more than their competitors and expect a level playing field. The owners are right about this. https://t.co/beNFDOaXNK
— Clay Travis (@ClayTravis) November 17, 2026
So what exactly is the players’ plan here, other than to ask for unlimited earning potential til the end of time? If they have an idea for how to increase revenues, increase spending, and create an overall atmosphere that benefits both sides — and lets fans feel like their team has a real chance to win — they should let everyone know and stop letting owners present themselves as the only ones thinking rationally about all this.
Again, public opinion will not settle these negotiations, but it definitely has a place. Players should show that they have good ideas to grow the game and keep everything appropriately competitive.
Owners are at least making fans feel seen, which can go a long way because perception often becomes reality for many. Players need to put forth a similar effort before the propaganda war becomes permanently one-sided.
Everyone just wants baseball — fans, owners, and players. But even the appearance of apathy for your customers is not in the recipe for long-term health.
More from this network:
Domains for Sale · GOTPeople.org · TheDSAPlatform · The Truth About Socialism
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Premium domains for sale
Comments (0)