Neither Left Nor Nationalist: Why Christ Doesn’t Fit Either Political Coalition

Nov 19, 2026 - 04:00
0 0
Neither Left Nor Nationalist: Why Christ Doesn’t Fit Either Political Coalition
Freedom Is Back In Style - 728x90 Ad

Premium domains for sale

Freedom Is Back In Style

FreedomIsBackInStyle .COM .NET .ORG WhereFreedomIsBackInStyle .COM .NET .ORG
Six-domain portfolio: $300,000 View Domains

There are a lot of unrecognizable interpretations of Christianity in America right now.

Freedom Is Back In Style - 300x250 Ad

Freedom Is Back
In Style

Premium domains for sale

FreedomIsBackInStyle.com .COM   .NET   .ORG
Packages from $100,000 View Domains

In Texas, incoming Democratic Senator James Talarico touted on the campaign trail that his Christian faith informs him to support abortion rights. And just this past weekend, across the same state, pastor Joel Webbon gathered political activists under the banner “Christ is King,” and speakers like Alex Jones, James Fishback, and Nick Fuentes took the stage to promote racial identity politics and a more explicitly white, male, Christian state.

Each side is trying to navigate Jesus to a different destination: one as a progressive, and one as a nationalist. Both seem convinced that the Son of God would have fit comfortably into their political coalition. Both are deeply flawed interpretations of the Word.

While respecting the separation of church and state, I take no issue with one’s faith guiding his politics. I’m a Christian first, conservative second. My faith informs my politics. In fact, I often say, “If you know my faith, you know my politics.” But these movements are the inverse. Each is trying to build political movements that redefine the faith itself.

Let’s start with Talarico, who in May 2026 claimed, “Jesus never talks about abortion. The Bible is silent on abortion.” Countless moral controversies today lack Jesus’ direct input. Christianity has never searched the Bible for modern political terms to determine moral exclusivity. My own Catholic faith is rooted in the dignity of human life, and the New Testament provides more than enough to support that. He would do well to peruse the Ten Commandments and slow down when he gets to the sixth. The absence of Talarico’s preferred vocabulary in Scripture is not permission to write his own.

Now to Webbon. At his Christ Is King gathering he told a room of 1,200 mostly white men that “White people are not going to go quietly into the night.” I feel terrible for the person who has to tell him that Jesus wasn’t white. But the broader point is that Christianity is not a racial inheritance. It is a universal faith.

Revelation 7:9 provides an inconvenient roadblock for Webbon as it describes “a vision of vast, unaccountable multitude from every nation, tribe, people, and language standing before the throne of God.” Again, the Gospel doesn’t belong to white people or Americans. And it certainly doesn’t belong to Joel Webbon. He and I do agree that Christ is King. For that reason, no political movement gets to crown itself His official representative.

Talarico and Webbon both let ideology determine which parts of Christianity to emphasize. The Left wants a Jesus who never judges. The nationalist Right wants a Jesus who never shows mercy. One treats the Gospel as a permission slip for progressive social policy. The other treats it as a mandate for political domination. But Christianity doesn’t call us to change Christ in our image. It demands that we change ourselves in his image.

Would I prefer that every person on Earth share my religion? Of course. I’m a Christian. But I’m also an American. And our Founders understood that religious liberty was essential to a free society. The First Amendment isn’t simply to protect Christians, and I don’t find that threatening. I find it essential.

Religious liberty cuts both ways. It protects Joel Webbon’s right to preach his understanding of Christianity, just as it protects Talarico’s right to express his. But it also protects my right to challenge both.

Talarico is free to use the Christian faith to promote abortion. But I’m equally free to point out that the dignity of human life isn’t some new Republican invention. Likewise, Webbon is free to advocate for a more explicitly white, male, Christian government. But I’m free to question whether elevating one religious identity through state power is consistent with the freedom of conscience and human dignity our faith demands.

That’s what I love about religious liberty. We can argue passionately about truth without giving the government a seat at the table. And that returns us to the fundamental question: What is happening to Christianity in America?

The internet would have you believe our faith is being torn apart. But I don’t see that when I examine my own life.

I see my own church packed with families at Sunday Mass. I see more athletes referencing God in postgame interviews. And I see ordinary Christians doing extraordinary things every day without an audience. And that’s why I’m so hopeful.

I converted to Catholicism because I came to believe the Church offered something the modern world couldn’t: truth that doesn’t change with the political winds, a moral framework that demands something of me, and a Savior who calls me to be a better man, husband, father, and neighbor.

I didn’t become Catholic to become a better Republican. I became a Catholic to become a better human.

Last Sunday’s Gospel preached the Parable of the Talents. In it, a master entrusts his servants with wealth and expects them to put it to good use. As Christians, we’ve been entrusted with something greater: The Gospel. As a father of four, I take my responsibility seriously: passing that gift to my children. Not a political translation of it. And someday I’ll have to answer for it.

And I’m incredibly optimistic. Christianity has survived 2,000 years of persecution, corruption, war, and political manipulation. It has outlasted emperors, empires, and countless men who tried to bend the faith to their ambitions. I’m confident it won’t be destroyed by a Texas Senator or an outgrowth of an online chatroom.

But for now, it wouldn’t hurt if more people tried to become like Jesus rather than attempt to make Jesus sound like them.

***

Gates Garcia is the host of the YouTube show and podcast “We The People.” Follow him on Instagram and X @GatesGarciaFL.


More from this network:
Domains for Sale · GOTPeople.org · TheDSAPlatform · The Truth About Socialism

Donate to GOTPeople.org

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0
Fibis

I am just an average American. My teen years were in the late 70s and I participated in all that that decade offered. Started working young, too young. Then I joined the Army before I graduated High School. I spent 25 years in, mostly in Infantry units. Since then I've worked in information technology positions all at small family owned companies. At this rate I'll never be a tech millionaire. When I was young I rode horses as much as I could. I do believe I should have been a cowboy. I'm getting in the saddle again by taking riding lessons and see where it goes.

Freedom Is Back In Style - 728x90 Ad

Premium domains for sale

Freedom Is Back In Style

FreedomIsBackInStyle .COM .NET .ORG WhereFreedomIsBackInStyle .COM .NET .ORG
Six-domain portfolio: $300,000 View Domains

Comments (0)

User