When Chanting ‘Christ is King’ Offends Christ
Premium domains for sale
Freedom Is Back In Style
If your social media algorithm was anything like mine over the weekend, you were involuntarily subjected to the absurd heights of “Christian Nationalism” vis-à-vis the “Christ is King” conference hosted by Joel Webbon’s clownish “New Christian Right” organization.
Freedom Is Back
In Style
Premium domains for sale
I hesitate to write this column if only because the cartoonish behavior and unbridled race-baiting tactics of those on stage aren’t intellectually serious. Long-settled bigotries repurposed and leveraged for digital virality remain what they are — transgressive idiocies. Nor are the individuals themselves serious persons. All the individuals involved are infamous for thriving on controversy, so giving them attention is exactly what they monetize and crave.
Nevertheless, it may still be worth drawing attention to it in hopes of exposing where late-stage “Christian Nationalism” is going and, hopefully, warning impressionable young men tempted by this movement not to go any further.
On stage were internet personalities like Alex Jones, J.P. Sears, James Fishback, Alex Stein, Nick Fuentes, and lesser-known hangers-on like Joel Webbon and Dale Partridge, drawing off the former group’s celebrity. What followed from the clips I saw was everything you would imagine and what critics of Christian Nationalism from across the spectrum have all predicted: The complete reduction of the Christian faith to power politics pursued through charlatanry, conspiracism, nativism, racism, and antisemitism. Their manner of argument is the mirror image of arguments made by leftists but retrofitted for white grievance. Replace many of the words they use (like “Jews,” “foreigner,” and “replacement”) with leftist shibboleths (like “oppressor,” “hegemony,” and “colonialism”), and you will see they are deploying the same arguments and rhetorical strategy as leftists. I’m old enough to remember when “conservatives” eschewed identity politics. But these are radicals, not conservatives.
The conference was a distilled form of right-wing identitarianism, the likes of which the sociologist Tobias Cremer argues in “Godless Crusade” is “politicizing Christianity as a secularized identity marker to mobilize voters in the context of a new social cleavage, centered around the question of identity and around a new wave of right-wing identity politics.” He goes on to argue that in previous eras, the “culture wars” of the 1980s–2010s were defined by religious interests, whereas the new form of Christian activism is “increasingly driven by a more secular but no less radical identitarian struggle for Western civilization: a godless crusade in which Christianity is turned into a secularized ‘Christianism,’ an ethno-cultural identifier of the nation and a symbol of whiteness that is increasingly independent of Christian practice, beliefs and the institution of the church.” In this paradigm, Christianity is a mere totem that coalesces tribal interests for political ends.
Cremer is right. If you want to see the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ reduced to little more than a tribal shibboleth for identity politics, no better display is on offer than what transpired over the weekend.
This should be an existential moment of self-reflection to see what has become of this movement. If anyone has followed online discourse for the past few years, both in evangelical discourse and national politics, Christian Nationalism has become a major focal point of debate. Some reasonable voices invoke “Christian Nationalism” to signal their desire to restore greater Christian influence in American society (which is good and welcome). Progressives, too, have been quick to blacklist any conservative Christian influence at all as some shade of “Christian Nationalism.” Then there are conservative evangelical critics like me who have warned, for years, that the label is too fraught, too historically toxic, and too theologically malignant for adoption.
Consider those concerns and warnings vindicated by what transpired at the aforementioned conference. But don’t say we weren’t warned.
Back in 2016, while at The New York Times, Catholic and conservative Ross Douthat tweeted something now legendary in the halls of the internet: “A thought sent back in time to the theocracy panic of 2005: If you dislike the religious right, wait till you meet the post-religious right.”
Theologian James Wood made a good observation about this weekend’s conference in light of Douthat’s prescience: While Douthat warned that the post-Christian Right would make the religious right look like teddy bears by comparison, most of today’s post-Christian right still claims the mantle of Christianity. In Wood’s telling, these efforts amount to wearing Christianity as a skinsuit for more toxic ideologies underneath. Violations of the Third Commandment in Exodus 20:7 (“You shall not take the name of the Lord in vain”) abounded in hollow, cringe-worthy chants of “Christ is King.” As Wood tells it, anyone remotely familiar with the fruits of Christianity would recognize the false teaching on display. But not before leading many young men astray. The figures of this form of Christian Nationalism are profiteering predators preying on the grievances of young men, whose grievances are sometimes legitimate and oftentimes exploited.
The clips showed an unalloyed demonstration of using Christ as a prop, devoid of saving grace. It’s the spirit of lowest-common-denominator nominalism that we are told will not redound in this newest form of Christian Nationalism. In truth, the chants of “Christ is King” are as jingoistic as any other predictable nationalist mantra would be.
What shall we make of this?
If the “Christ is King”-chanting Christian Nationalists are bearing the fruits of darkness, then of course, let’s trust them when they say they can keep a whole nation Christian, too. Showing that even those claiming the name of Christ are betraying him, how could we ever expect anything different from a nation that believes itself Christian while emptying the faith of its actual substance — salvation by grace through faith? If the individuals who bear his name can be so repugnantly guilty of reducing Christianity to some useful measure of social cohesion, a nation comprised of religiously mixed persons cannot do so, either. This is not a call to surrender the public square, but to keep our loyalties and allegiances clear as we fight for truth, goodness, and justice. We cannot expect a whole nation to be a disciple, but we should expect justice.
But something else needs to be said: This is where the terminal embrace of “Christian Nationalism” was always destined to go — even by those who, I’ll acknowledge, wish to redeem the term for more reasonable and moderate ends. But it cannot stay moderate. Its advocates distort Scripture from the roots up by extracting a use of “nations” that exceeds Scriptural warrant. It necessarily breeds extremism because it uses Machiavellian means for Darwinian ends. When Christ is little more than agitprop, the fruit of the Spirit in Galatians 5 takes a back seat to vanquishing one’s enemies by whatever means necessary.
One suspects that in some not-too-distant future, the Christian pretense of this movement will give way to what it is really after: Political power pursued for ethno-national ends. Jesus will cease to be a useful hood ornament once what is desired is made plain, as it was in this conference. All movements that claim Scripture verbally but deny it ethically eventually flame out in the same types of heresies. Once you understand that for many, Jesus is just a means to get you something else, the need to confess Him even falsely will give way to fully jettisoning him. We should remember that a true account of “Christ is King” means accepting his Lordship, rejecting hypocrisy, and loving our enemies.
So what use will the term be now that antisemites and racial realists openly embrace both? Hopefully increasingly little.
If I were one of the more responsible proponents of Christian Nationalism, I would ask myself: Have I created a plausibility structure through which others have laundered the most heinous, juvenile, vile, and extreme forms of baptized hate that are on display at this conference?
And I think the answer would be yes.
***
Andrew T. Walker, Ph.D., is Dean of the School of Theology at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary and Professor of Christian Ethics and Public Theology. He is a Fellow with The Ethics and Public Policy Center and the Managing Editor of WORLD Opinions. You can follow him on X: @AndrewTWalker.
More from this network:
Domains for Sale · GOTPeople.org · TheDSAPlatform · The Truth About Socialism
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Premium domains for sale
Comments (0)