Immigrant Ingratitude: The Call Is Coming From Inside the House

America is the most generous nation on earth. For centuries, we have opened our doors to millions seeking freedom and opportunity. Legal immigrants who came the right way—learning our language, embracing our culture, and working hard—built this country alongside native-born Americans. They showed gratitude and became part of the American family.

Tragically, recent open-border policies betrayed that tradition. We let in millions more, many illegally and unvetted, with little expectation of assimilation. Far too many have taken extreme advantage of our generosity and compassion, exploiting our welfare systems, public services, and openness while offering contempt in return.

I’ll tell you what—American taxpayers and patriots don’t view all-access immigration as a victimless policy. It creates real victims among our own citizens through severe downstream effects: suppressed wages for working families, overwhelmed schools and hospitals, rising crime in communities that never asked for this transformation, and cultural fragmentation that weakens our national identity and social trust.

If we obsess over carbon footprints, we should pay at least as much attention to immigration footprints: net fiscal impact, effects on native wages, crime and security costs, and success at assimilation rather than fragmentation.

What is the minimum we should expect from those who enter this country? Gratitude. Assimilation. Respect for our laws. Self-sufficiency. Loyalty to the United States.

These are not unreasonable demands. Every nation has the right—and the obligation—to conduct a cost-benefit analysis of its immigration policies. The relevant question is simple: Does this immigrant strengthen America or weaken it? Does this person contribute more than he consumes? Does he embrace our country or resent it? Does he add to our civic fabric or fray it?

Immigration is not an entitlement. It is a privilege extended by a sovereign nation to those who will strengthen it. America is not an all-you-can-eat buffet where anyone can arrive, take what they want, reject the house rules, and demand more. Nor should Americans subsidize entitled enemies who openly disdain the country that welcomed them.

When newcomers reject these obligations, our compassion is weaponized against us. A successful immigration system maximizes rewards, minimizes risks, and always puts American citizens first.

Recall the horror classic “When a Stranger Calls.” The terrified babysitter receives ominous phone calls from a killer she believes is outside the house. Police trace the call … only to discover the nightmare truth: “The call is coming from inside the house.”

That is America’s reality today. The threat is inside our house—in our cities, institutions, and positions of power.

This is why our leaders owe it to their constituents to heed the call from inside the house before it’s too late.

The proven policy solutions are clear and must be implemented aggressively: immigration restraint as well as onshoring and protectionism.

Immigration restraint means securing the border completely, ending catch-and-release, pursuing mass deportations of criminals and recent illegal entrants, requiring nationwide E-Verify, and shutting down sanctuary cities and welfare magnets. Above all, it means shifting to a strict merit-based system that prioritizes high-skilled contributors who assimilate and show genuine gratitude—those with small immigration footprints.

Onshoring and protectionism means bringing factories and jobs back home through targeted tariffs, tax incentives, and Buy American rules. This raises wages for working Americans, revives communities, and builds the economic strength needed to sustain controlled immigration that actually benefits the nation.

These America First policies work. Controlled immigration paired with domestic economic nationalism raises wages, stabilizes communities, and makes gratitude sustainable. Previous generations have proved that this approach builds the world’s greatest middle class.

We have traced the call. The ingrates inside the house continue demanding open borders and permanent globalism. We demand better. Implement these solutions now: Restrain immigration to end exploitation and bring jobs home to restore prosperity and security for American workers and families.

No free lunches. No free rides. When generosity is met with exploitation instead of gratitude, all bets are off.

The house is ours. We are taking it back—stronger, safer, more prosperous, and unapologetically American.

We publish a variety of perspectives. Nothing written here is to be construed as representing the views of the Daily Signal.