When ‘Everyone Is Welcome’ Comes With Conditions

This article is part of Upstream, The Daily Wire’s new home for culture and lifestyle. Real human insight and human stories — from our featured writers to you.

***

The Brooklyn coffee shop Poetica describes hospitality in almost spiritual terms. Its website promises “unconditional dignity.” It says “the guest is sacred.” It talks about welcoming people as human beings rather than transactions and creating a place where everyone is treated with respect.

Then Rep. Dan Goldman walked in for a cup of coffee with his daughter.

Goldman wasn’t accused of causing a disturbance. He wasn’t accused of being rude to employees. He bought a coffee and left. Later, the shop mocked him online, refunded his purchase, and suggested it wouldn’t have served him had staff known who he was. The problem was his support for Israel.

Apparently the guest is sacred right up until he has the wrong views. The politics are almost secondary. Americans disagree passionately about Israel, Gaza, and foreign policy. That’s normal. What’s more revealing is how quickly a person can stop being a person and become a symbol.

Goldman walked into that shop as a customer. By the end of the day, he had become a stand-in for everything the owners disliked. He wasn’t Dan Goldman anymore. He was a collection of political positions wrapped into a single human being. Once that happens, normal rules no longer seem to apply.

You don’t have to treat someone with dignity if you’ve convinced yourself he’s part of a cause you despise. You don’t have to be hospitable. You don’t even have to leave him alone after he buys a cup of coffee. In fact, publicly humiliating him can start to feel justified and like a moral act.

Goldman may have been the target, but he wasn’t the audience. The audience was everyone else. The post was a public declaration: This is who we are, and this is who we are against.

There was a time when a customer was just a customer. Today, it sometimes feels as though every interaction must be filtered through politics. A cup of coffee becomes a statement. A customer becomes a symbol. A disagreement becomes a moral emergency. Hence why a congressman buying coffee became an opportunity for public shaming rather than an ordinary transaction. The owners saw an enemy where most people would have seen a customer.

It’s worth noting that Goldman isn’t a Republican. He’s a Democrat. The people celebrating his public humiliation aren’t reacting to a Trump ally or a MAGA activist. They’re reacting to someone who holds the “wrong” view on a single issue.

That’s often how ideological movements evolve. At first, the targets are obvious opponents. Eventually, disagreement itself becomes the problem. People who once belonged suddenly find themselves cast out for failing to embrace the latest orthodoxy.

The coffee shop’s website actually contains a better idea than the one reflected in its social media post. “The guest is sacred” is a wonderful principle precisely because it doesn’t require agreement. It asks us to treat people decently, even when we strongly disagree with them.

Anyone can be welcoming to people who share their worldview. Anyone can extend dignity to allies. The test comes when someone you dislike walks through the door. The Brooklyn coffee shop failed that test. More troublingly, many people seemed to think it passed.

The website says the guest is sacred. It’s hard to read that line now without adding an asterisk.

***